[Hamara-devel] Sugam on Debian and the about page.

[Amardeep Singh]

Hi All,

First of all thanks to shirish for devoting his time and effort in 
explaining in such detail.

I have added my few comments/thought's inline.
On Monday 23 March 2015 09:30 PM, shirish शिरीष wrote:
> Hi all,
>
> There are and were lots of thoughts after my discussion with Vikas on
> Friday evening, but as week-end happened and had to meet with friends
> and socialize a bit. As the about page would and should be a
> collaborative effort, some numbers, some discussion before making
> writing them are in order but even before building sugam using debian
> note which Vikas shared and my thoughts why I said it's better to have
> or use Debian as the base even now than Ubuntu/Canonical.
>
> a. It doesn't make any sense other than to say that we have done sugam
> using Ubuntu (kind of like bragging right) but as far as support or
> anything is concerned we wouldn't be able to give/share any of that.
> Even how much testing we would be able to do ourselves is not known at
> this point of time. If it's on Ubuntu I would probably not be so
> inclined to volunteer my time on that, on Debian it would directly or
> indirectly serve Debian as well because if any bugs we uncover (if and
> when) it would help to make Debian better as well as upstream. On
> Canonical/Ubuntu I haven't seen them collaborate on the same level, so
> in a sense the commons are served. This serves both ethical and
> commercial interests as resources are being used where there is no
> danger of being withered away.
I would agree with this Shirish. Ubuntu doesn't seems to be collaborate 
well. They are mostly working
in there own shell and only fix what they think is correct, not what 
community needs.

This was one of the reasons to keep Hamara always open for community.
>
> b. If you look at the differences between Ubuntu and Debian, that
> would be around 20% and Unity is one of the major differences in
> there, apart from that there is no much difference (except if you take
> Canonical partner offerings but that is a different story altogether.)
>
> c. The other reason which I think I shared or didn't share in my
> earlier post is flexibility. In Debian I could use the BSD kernel or
> GNU Hurd if the situation so requires (although when and if GNU Hurd
> would become a reality is another story in itself) but this is
> possible because of de-coupling or not having hard paths to a specific
> kernel type. This is and would not be true of Canonical.
>
> For Debian see https://www.debian.org/ports/kfreebsd-gnu/ and
> https://www.debian.org/ports/hurd/ . You can find quite a good lists
> of the various ports and their progress at
> https://www.debian.org/ports/ - look at both the official and
> unofficial ports to have an understanding of the depth of both the
> range of the efforts and people trying to do them.
This is really interesting. I'll read up more in hurd.
>
> So, the hard path would probably be tackling d-i (debian-installer)
> but this is precisely where people could help. What would be needed is
> the latest snapshot of debian-installer, the installation-report
> package (already part of d-i) and putting whatever modifications made
> to the UI. See https://www.debian.org/devel/debian-installer/ and see
> the mailing list archives of debian-boot
> https://lists.debian.org/debian-boot/2015/03/threads.html . There is
> also #debian-boot on oftc for help and support.
In my opinion we can stick to ubiquity for as installer. I am sure we 
can run that on debian.
>
> Another tool people could look at would be boxer as have heard good
> things about it but as haven't used it can't say one way or the other
> (haven't needed to) https://wiki.debian.org/FreedomBox/Tools
>
> d. Another interesting sub-project which was taken and is being taken
> seriously by folks is using clang to uncover compiler errors alongwith
> gcc. See http://clang.debian.net/ .
>
> All of the above shows that people have real reasons for choosing and
> using Debian as a base (for me it's all bugs in the open except for
> CVE's) and getting timely support.
>
> Apart from all above, if you use Ubuntu now and then want to switch to
> Debian that will involve pain both in terms of tools, time and
> knowledge which will be completely unnecessary with lower costs now
> then in the future.
>
> This concludes my comments about building sugam on Debian.
I will agree on this to base sugam on Debian. Looking at advantages 
detailed here, we should also look at how much
work is involved to move Hamara Desktop to debian.

>
> Now for the about page two re-curring themes were there with Vikas
> while we were chatting/discussing on the phone.
>
> a. Localization - This is where we have been bad, how bad we are at it
> can be guaged at https://www.debian.org/international/l10n/po/hi (if
> we just take hindi at the language to be handled)  I have shared some
> brief on that at
> https://flossexperiences.wordpress.com/2014/11/05/debutsav-2014-experiences-day-2/
> but as shared have no real expertise on it. Having more people having
> hands-on and adding to the .po files would help all and any free
> software immeasurably while helping development of Sugam itself. This
> is a huge problem area but if we are able to do move some tiny
> percentages on it, the benefits are immense. As an e.g. you could take
> Nokia's making money off cheap mobiles which used local languages as a
> starting point, the point is, if the language of all different parts
> of the desktop and softwares are in local language, the take-up would
> be larger, English as a language is a barrier for many Indians and
> hence technology. If technologies such as Raspberry Pi2 or beaglebone
> black or any of the newer ARM-based devices could be delivered to
> people in local language, there is and would be a quantum leap in
> understanding, doing business, entertainment etc. which we can't think
> of. Just think of a kid sitting somewhere and using blender in his/her
> local language and making an animated movie on his Pi2, just blows the
> mind. There are unlimited use-cases for localization and the
> 'job'/work  is well-defined, just need people who know it, are
> passionate about it and willing to devote time on it.
Localization was one of our primary targets. The vision is to cover as 
much as languages we can in Hamara with combination of ARM architecture.

This is very well explained here. We should write the vision on website 
as well, so people can contribute to localization.
>
> b. EDA - The global EDA industry is somewhere between 9 to 19 billion
> dollars depending on whose numbers you believe in. India would
> probably be somewhere in 1 or 2 percent as there is some EDA happening
> but Modi's 'Make in India' could probably change that. Add to that
> technologies which would influence the EDA industry i.e. IOT, Wearable
> Computing, Mobile and Social, each of which are estimated to each
> generate around 250 billion dollars world-wide by 2020, the
> opportunities are unlimited. It's how much risk we are willing to
> take. There is quite a bit of EDA tools in FOSS which go hand-in-hand
> in the whole open-source hardware philosophy as well. There was an
> initiative to package FOSS EDA tools number of years back (a friend of
> mine Archis Gore and me and several others) , we did a release but
> were unable to do much due to number of reasons (one of the top being
> the students our main target group didn't have FOSS in syllabus) so
> all the effort went into drain. This is/was about 10 years back. Tools
> have grown a lot since then but would need somebody who is passionate
> about the EDA industry and can share his/her wisdom with the rest of
> us.
>
> c. Sell systems with Hamara Linux - Don't need to say more. Actually
> have shared quite of my own quandary at
> https://flossexperiences.wordpress.com/2014/11/05/debutsav-2014-experiences-day-2/
>
> Both the ideas as shared by Vikas are rich and have untold dividends.
> I am excited to be part of hamaralinux as we get the show on the road
> :)
This was a really nice post. I am really convinced to move to debian base.

Thanks,
Amardeep